By Peter M. Beck
1 June 2009 Korea Herald, Weekly Chosun, Nelson Report, and Atlantic Council Highlights
I have been deeply moved by the outpouring of sympathy for former President Roh Moo-hyun in the wake of his suicide on May 23. As the shock and sadness begin to subside, rather than assigning blame (there is plenty to go around), we must seek solutions to the underlying sources of this tragedy. Unless an increasingly poisonous political culture and a burgeoning suicide rate are confronted, South Korea will soon be known not just as the “Kingdom of Corruption” but also the “Republic of Suicides.”
The Western media has focused on the Supreme Prosecutors’ Office’s investigations into corruption by Roh’s family members as the primary motivation for jumping to his death from Owl Rock. Many foreign reports have also noted that each of his four predecessors were either jailed or had family members who were found guilty of corruption. It is unfortunate that the Roh family could not discern this pattern and resist the temptation to accept illicit funds. My only hope that a similar fate will not befall President Lee Myung-bak is that fact that he was already wealthy before he became president.
Indeed, the judiciary is obligated to investigate crimes committed by public servants and their family members. The problem is the courts’ selective enforcement of the law. Sadly, prosecutors are still widely seen as little more than lap dogs of the political party in power. Using the law for political retribution is a tactic that is alive and well in Korea.
Unfortunately, announcing immediately after Roh’s suicide that all investigations would be halted only reinforces the notion that the investigation was politically motivated. It also sends the disturbing message to future officials facing prosecution that they can clear their names by committing suicide.
President Roh was clearly troubled, if not depressed, by the jailing of his brother and the prosecutorial grilling his wife and son had been subjected to. However, each of his predecessors had faced a similar if not worse fate, and are all still alive. Former President George W. Bush is responsible for the deaths of over 4,000 American soldiers as a result of his botched invasion of a country that posed no threat to the U.S. Yet, Bush has actually made jokes about not finding weapons of mass destruction in Iraq and is perfectly content to let history judge him. Why was Roh different?
There are generally two motivations for taking one’s own life: psychological and situational. Those suffering from chronic depression, bipolarity and other forms of mental illness can succumb to their own inner demons. The second group have either committed or observed an act or had something happen to them that they are unable to deal with. Roh appears to have been driven by a mix of the two motivations. While his childhood friends insist that he was not the type of person who would commit suicide, Roh ultimately could not cope with his family’s transgressions or the politics of revenge.
At the same time, I cannot help but wonder if Roh’s supporters are best serving his memory by refusing to allow Grand National Party leaders to pay their respects. Roh was a divisive leader in life, but clearly did not wish to be so in death. His 14-line suicide note includes, “Do not hold a grudge against anyone.” Reconciliation with North Korea may not be possible so long as Chairman Kim Jong-il and his inner circle are in power, but shouldn’t we try to fulfill President Roh’s dying wish for reconciliation among South Koreans of all political and regional stripes?
Despite Roh’s noble intentions, in Western eyes, suicide is an inherently selfish and dishonorable act that causes unspeakable pain and suffering for the loved ones they leave behind. My heart broke when I saw the words of anguish uttered by Roh’s wife and daughter. Regrettably, I have had a taste of their grief. An uncle who was living a seemingly ordinary middle class life with a patient wife and two daughters could not escape from the grip of chronic depression. He took his own life less than a year after my grandmother died. I also lost a good friend who worked at the Bank of Korea. He had an absolutely lovely wife and two sweet boys. Just weeks after our families had the most wonderful time exploring Nam-san, I received the shocking news that he had taken his own life. I still have pangs of guilt that I was not able to do more to help my uncle and Korean friend to choose to live. I try to understand the mental suffering they must have lived with, but I cannot comprehend suffering so great that they could abandon their families.
President Roh is only the third head of state to take his own life in the past 100 years (the others are Adolf Hitler and former Chilean President Salvador Allende, who was about to be ousted in a military coup in 1973). Unfortunately, Roh’s suicide is part of a larger, troubling trend. Korea has the highest suicide rate in the world for women and is the highest overall among developed countries, more than double the rate of the United States. Group suicides are now common. A dozen actors and actresses, including my favorite Korean actress, Choi Jin-sil, have killed themselves in the past few years.
In much of Asia, there is a long tradition of committing suicide in order to preserve one’s family honor. Is suicide becoming socially acceptable behavior? The decision by the Korean media to adopt the most honorific and exalted word to describe President Roh’s death (seo-geo) may have been primarily out of respect and sympathy, but I cannot help but conclude that it also provides legitimacy for his actions.
It may be too much to expect Korea to develop a less poisonous political culture anytime soon, but it is not too much to ask the government to adopt a much more aggressive suicide prevention program. Korea is not alone. The United States is also confronting a surge in suicides, but with a more limited segment of its population. Suicides in the U.S. military are at an all-time high as a result of more than six years of repeated deployments to Iraq. More soldiers committed suicide in January 2009 than died in combat in Iraq and Afghanistan combined. The Obama Administration recognizes that this is a crisis. How about President Lee?
See Beck's Jan. 2007 Article